Runner's Guide to Orlando Trail Surfaces: Best Shoes for Every Local Trail

Orlando may not have mountains, but we've got miles of exceptional running trails that draw everyone from casual joggers to ultramarathon trainers. What we also have—and what catches many runners off guard—is an incredible variety of surfaces, each demanding different things from your feet and footwear.

As Orlando podiatrists who treat local runners daily (and log plenty of miles ourselves), we've created this comprehensive guide to help you choose the right shoes for every trail in the greater Orlando area.

The Major Paved Trails

West Orange Trail

The Details:

• Length: 22 miles from Killarney Station to Apopka
• Surface: Asphalt with occasional concrete sections
• Elevation: Essentially flat (this is Florida)
• Shade Coverage: Approximately 40% shaded
• Key Access Points: Killarney Station, Winter Garden Station, Chapin Station

Surface Analysis: The West Orange Trail is primarily smooth asphalt, well-maintained by Orange County. It's one of the best surfaces in Orlando for running—consistent, predictable, and relatively forgiving. The concrete sections near road crossings are noticeably harder, so be aware of transitions. Best Shoes for West Orange Trail:

• Road Running Shoes: This is textbook road running territory
• Recommended: Brooks Ghost, HOKA Clifton, Asics Nimbus, Nike Pegasus
• Cushioning Level: Medium to high cushioning works well
• Avoid: Trail shoes (unnecessary traction, heavier weight)

Podiatry Considerations:

• The flat, consistent surface is excellent for runners recovering from injuries
• Long straightaways can cause repetitive stress; vary your pace
• The Winter Garden downtown section has some brick pavers—watch your ankles
• Restrooms available at multiple stations (plan hydration accordingly)

Local Runner Tip: Start at Killarney Station for the most consistent surface. The section between Winter Garden and Apopka has some rougher patches where roots have lifted the asphalt.

---

Cady Way Trail

The Details:

• Length: 6.5 miles from Fashion Square Mall to Cross Seminole Trail
• Surface: Smooth asphalt
• Elevation: Flat with one overpass
• Shade Coverage: About 50% shaded
• Key Access Points: Fashion Square Mall, Cady Way Pool, Baldwin Park

Surface Analysis: Cady Way is exceptionally well-maintained—possibly the smoothest trail surface in Orlando. The asphalt is newer in most sections, and the trail passes through the beautifully planned Baldwin Park community where upkeep is immaculate. Best Shoes for Cady Way Trail:

• Road Running Shoes: Standard road trainers are perfect
• Recommended: Any quality road shoe—surface is forgiving
• Cushioning Level: Personal preference; surface is consistent
• Great for speed work due to predictable surface

Podiatry Considerations:

• Excellent for interval training and tempo runs
• The Baldwin Park section is popular with strollers—watch for sudden stops
• Connects to Cross Seminole Trail for longer runs (total 10+ miles one way)
• Water fountains at Cady Way Pool area

Local Runner Tip: Park at the lot on Bennett Road near Baldwin Park. The section through Baldwin Park village has clean restrooms at Publix.

---

Seminole Wekiva Trail

The Details:

• Length: 14 miles from Lake Mary to Wekiva Springs
• Surface: Asphalt with some concrete sections
• Elevation: Slight rolling hills near Wekiva
• Shade Coverage: 60-70% heavily wooded
• Key Access Points: Lake Mary Publix, Longwood, Wekiva Springs State Park

Surface Analysis: More rustic than West Orange or Cady Way. The surface has more patches, cracks, and root heaves, especially in the northern sections near Wekiva. The shade is fantastic in summer, but tree roots are the trade-off. Best Shoes for Seminole Wekiva Trail:

• Road Shoes with Good Stability: Look for mild trail-road hybrids
• Recommended: Brooks Cascadia, Altra Lone Peak, Saucony Peregrine, Nike Pegasus Trail
• Cushioning Level: Medium cushion with ground feel
• Ankle Support: Consider shoes with slightly higher collars

Podiatry Considerations:

• Root heaves require ankle mobility and stability
• Uneven surfaces increase proprioceptive demand
• Great for building foot/ankle strength
• Watch for armadillo holes near trail edges (yes, really)

Local Runner Tip: The section from Longwood to Wekiva is the most challenging but also the most beautiful. Bring bug spray—we're near wetlands.

---

Little Eola Trail / Orlando Urban Trail

The Details:

• Length: 3.5 miles connecting Lake Eola to Colonialtown
• Surface: Concrete and asphalt mix
• Elevation: Flat
• Shade Coverage: Limited (urban setting)
• Key Access Points: Lake Eola Park, Colonialtown North

Surface Analysis: This urban connector trail runs through established Orlando neighborhoods. Surface quality varies significantly—some sections are smooth concrete, others are older asphalt with cracks and patches. Sidewalk transitions are common. Best Shoes for Little Eola Trail:

• Road Running Shoes: Standard road shoes work
• Recommended: Choose responsive shoes for frequent surface changes
• Cushioning Level: Medium (too much can feel unstable on uneven concrete)
• Watch for: Curb transitions and driveway ramps

Podiatry Considerations:

• Frequent surface transitions challenge ankle stability
• Street crossings require quick stops—be ready
• Good for variety but not ideal for zone-out long runs

---

Natural Surface Trails

Tibet-Butler Nature Preserve

The Details:

• Length: 4+ miles of interconnected trails
• Surface: Packed sand, pine needles, some boardwalks
• Elevation: Gentle rolling
• Shade Coverage: 80%+ heavy canopy
• Location: South Orange County, near Lake Tibet

Surface Analysis: This is as close to "trail running" as Orlando gets. The packed sand and pine needle surface is significantly softer than asphalt—a welcome relief for joints but demanding different muscles. Wooden boardwalks over wetland areas add variety (and slip risk when wet). Best Shoes for Tibet-Butler:

• Trail Running Shoes: Essential for traction and protection
• Recommended: Salomon Speedcross, Altra Lone Peak, Brooks Caldera, HOKA Speedgoat
• Traction: Aggressive lugs for sandy sections
• Protection: Rock plates helpful for root/rock encounters

Podiatry Considerations:

• Sand running activates different foot muscles; ease into distance
• Pine needles hide roots and rocks—trail shoes are non-negotiable
• are common here; if you have ider stability shoes or tape
• The softer surface is excellent for injury recovery

Local Runner Tip: Best running is early morning before it gets hot. The Fallen Log Trail loop is the most runner-friendly.

---

Hal Scott Regional Preserve

The Details:

• Length: 10+ miles of trails
• Surface: Packed dirt, sand, some grassy sections
• Elevation: Flat (former ranch land)
• Shade Coverage: Variable (pine flatwoods, open prairie)
• Location: East Orange County near UCF

Surface Analysis: A hidden gem for trail running. The surface is primarily hard-packed dirt with sandy stretches. The open prairie sections can be soft sand, especially after rain. Pine flatwoods offer harder surfaces. Minimal root hazards compared to northern trails. Best Shoes for Hal Scott:

• Trail Running Shoes: Needed for sand and dirt
• Recommended: Moderate traction trail shoes; don't need aggressive lugs
• Watch for: Soft sand sections that demand extra effort

Podiatry Considerations:

• Running in sand strengthens intrinsic foot muscles
• Soft sand increases Achilles stress—build up gradually
• Flat terrain good for beginners to trail running
• Sun exposure significant—protect feet from heat

---

Wekiwa Springs State Park Trails

The Details:

• Length: 8+ miles of trails
• Surface: Sand, packed dirt, roots
• Elevation: Some gentle hills (Florida standards)
• Shade Coverage: Heavy in most areas
• Location: Apopka/Longwood

Surface Analysis: Challenging Central Florida trail running. Deep sandy sections, significant root exposure, and narrower single-track than preserve trails. This is where Orlando trail runners go to build real skills. Best Shoes for Wekiwa Springs:

• Technical Trail Shoes: Need good traction and protection
• Recommended: Salomon Sense Ride, La Sportiva Bushido, HOKA Speedgoat
• Essential Features: Rock plate, aggressive traction, debris-shedding upper
• Gaiters: Consider sand/debris gaiters

Podiatry Considerations:

• Highest risk of Orlando trails
• Sandy descents challenge anterior ti
• Great for building proprioception and foot strength
• Start with shorter loops if new to trail running

Local Runner Tip: Do the Blue Trail loop for a challenging but manageable 5-mile run. Bring cash for park entry fee.

---

Specialty Running Surfaces

UCF Track (Orlando)

Surface: All-weather rubber track Best Shoes: Racing flats, spikes for speed work, road shoes for easy laps Podiatry Notes: Forgiving surface; excellent for interval training and injury recovery. The consistent curve stresses one leg differently—alternate directions.

Chain of Lakes Park (Winter Haven—worth the drive)

Surface: Crushed shell paths Best Shoes: Trail shoes or rugged road shoes Podiatry Notes: Unique surface that's softer than concrete but more stable than sand. Great variety for foot muscles.

Lake Underhill Park

Surface: Concrete path, grass options Best Shoes: Road shoes; grass running barefoot-style optional Podiatry Notes: The grass alongside the path offers a nice recovery surface. Watch for hidden sprinkler heads.

---

Common Injuries by Trail Type

Paved Trail Injuries

: Repetitive impact on hard surfaces

• Prevention: Adequate cushioning, gradual mileage increases, calf stretching

Shin Splints: Especially common on concrete sections

• Prevention: Avoid heel striking, strengthen anterior tibialis, proper shoe rotation

Knee Pain: The flat surfaces don't challenge stabilizers

• Prevention: Mix paved and natural surface running, strengthen hips

Natural Trail Injuries

: The #1 trail running injury

• Prevention: Trail-specific shoes, ankle strengthening exercises, tape if needed

Metatarsalgia: Rocks and roots concentrate pressure

• Prevention: Shoes with rock plates, strengthening intrinsic foot muscles

Achilles Issues: Sand running overloads the calf/Achilles complex

• Prevention: Gradual introduction to sand, proper warm-up, adequate recovery

---

Seasonal Considerations for Orlando Runners

Summer (June-September)

• Run early (before 7 AM) or late (after 7 PM)
• Heat radiates from asphalt—trail surfaces are cooler
• Hydration absolutely critical
• Hot surfaces can cause blistering; check shoe temperatures

Fall (October-November)

• Best running weather in Orlando
• Trails may be muddy after hurricanes
• runDisney training season—trails get crowded

Winter (December-February)

• Morning runs may encounter frost (rare but happens)
• Snowbirds increase trail traffic significantly
• Best time for long paved trail runs

Spring (March-May)

• Pollen can be extreme—consider allergies and breathing
• Humidity returns; adjust pace expectations
• Great time for natural trail running before summer heat

---

Building a Balanced Orlando Running Routine

For optimal foot health and injury prevention, we recommend:

Weekly Mix:

• 2 runs on paved trails (West Orange, Cady Way) for consistent training
• 1 run on natural surfaces (Tibet-Butler, Hal Scott) for foot/ankle strengthening
• 1 cross-training or recovery day

Shoe Rotation:

• 2-3 pairs of road shoes rotating for paved trails
• 1 pair of trail shoes for natural surfaces
• Retire shoes at 300-500 miles

---

When to See a Podiatrist

If you're an Orlando runner experiencing:

• Pain that persists more than a week despite rest
• Pain that changes your running gait
• Any swelling, bruising, or visible abnormality
• Numbness or tingling in feet
• Pain that worsens during runs (not just after)

Don't wait until you're forced to stop running. Early intervention keeps runners on their trails.

---

About Orlando's Feet: We're runners who treat runners. Our practice specializes in sports podiatry with a focus on keeping Central Florida's running community healthy and on the trails.